I'm in contract and the lender I was pre-approved with already ordered the appraisal. Can I have the appraisal transferred, and is it too late?
By Kyle Melvin · NMLS #1486450 · REV Mortgage ·
Short answer
Yes, and it is rarely too late. On a VA loan the appraisal is tied to the VA case for that property, not to the lender who ordered it, and the VA Lenders Handbook says the lender who ordered it must transfer the case to your new lender when you ask in writing. You do not order or pay for a second appraisal. What decides whether there is still time is your contract's closing date, because the new lender has to underwrite the loan from the start.
On a VA loan the appraisal was never the first lender's to keep. The lender ordered it through VA's system, VA assigned the appraiser, and the result is attached to a VA case number for you and that house. Chapter 10 of the VA Lenders Handbook, under "Request from the Veteran to Change Lenders," says lenders are expected to cooperate when a veteran decides to change lenders, and that the lender who ordered the appraisal must transfer the case to the new lender when the veteran asks in writing. Email counts as writing.
How the transfer works
- Pick the new lender first. Ask them for the email address, phone number and VA lender ID they want the case sent to. The Handbook tells the new lender to give you exactly those three things.
- Send the first lender a short written request. Name the property, say you are changing lenders, and ask them to transfer the VA case and appraisal to the new lender, with those details. Two or three sentences is enough. You do not owe an explanation.
- The first lender's appraisal reviewer moves the case in VA's system. It is a few minutes of work on their side. In practice it takes a day or two, and a follow-up call.
- The new lender picks up where the appraisal stands. If the appraiser has not been out yet, the order carries on. If the report is done, the new lender reviews it and issues the Notice of Value.
The value and any repair conditions come with it. Changing lenders does not get you a second opinion on a low appraisal; that is what Tidewater and a Reconsideration of Value are for. A Notice of Value on an existing home is good for six months, so the appraisal itself is not what runs out.
Is it too late?
There is no point in a VA purchase after which the appraisal can no longer move. What runs out is the calendar in your contract. The appraisal transfers; the rest of the file does not. The new lender takes a new application, pulls its own credit, collects your income and asset documents again, underwrites from the start and sends new disclosures. Federal disclosure rules also put three business days between the Closing Disclosure and signing, and no lender can shorten that. Your rate lock with the first lender stays with the first lender.
So the honest test is this: ask the new lender for the date they can close, in writing, before you send the transfer request. If that date is inside your contract, switch. If it is not, the seller has to agree to an extension, and a seller with a backup offer may say no. A week before closing, with a seller who will not move, staying put can be the better call even with a lender you have stopped trusting. The VA loan process page shows what has to happen between contract and closing, and how long a VA loan takes covers the usual pace.
If it is not a VA loan
FHA works much the same way: the appraisal is tied to an FHA case number, and HUD's handbook requires the first lender to transfer the case when the borrower asks. A conventional loan is different. No rule makes the first lender release the appraisal. Most will, with a transfer letter, and the new lender decides whether to accept it. If either says no, you pay for a new one. Ask both lenders before you commit to the switch.
Whatever the loan type, ask the new lender the things you wish you had asked the first one. The questions to ask a lender page is the list.
Questions people also ask
- Can I transfer my VA appraisal to a new lender?
- Yes. Chapter 10 of the VA Lenders Handbook says lenders are expected to cooperate when a veteran changes lenders, and the lender who ordered the appraisal must transfer the case to the new lender when the veteran asks in writing. Email counts.
- Do I have to pay for a second appraisal if I switch lenders?
- Not on a VA loan. The same appraisal and the same value move with the case to the new lender. If you have not yet paid the appraiser's fee for the first one, you still owe it.
- Is it too late to switch lenders once I am under contract?
- No rule sets a cutoff. The limit is the closing date in your contract: the new lender needs time to underwrite the file, issue new disclosures and lock a rate, and if that runs past the date you need the seller to agree to an extension.
- Can the first lender refuse to release the appraisal?
- Not on a VA loan. If a lender will not act on a written request, the VA Regional Loan Center for the property's state can step in. On a conventional loan the first lender is not required to release it.

Have this exact question about your own file?
Send Kyle the details — orders, LES, the house, the COE — and get the answer for your situation, not the general one.
A free 30-minute call, booked on Calendly.